Mailbag 39: “What Does the Fox Say?” – With Dr Nathan Fox

In this episode of Healthful Woman, Dr. Nathan Fox answers listener questions on fertility, breastfeeding, contraception, and pregnancy after uterine surgery. He discusses nursing while trying to conceive, insufficient glandular tissue and milk supply, IUDs in a misshapen uterus, uterine incisions and VBAC, and pregnancy after myomectomy. Throughout the episode, Dr. Fox explores what the available evidence can, and cannot, tell us about these important women’s health questions.

Share this post:

Welcome to today’s episode of “Healthful Woman,” a podcast designed to explore topics in women’s health at all stages of life. I am your host, Dr. Nathan Fox, an OBGYN and maternal fetal medicine specialist practicing in New York City. At “Healthful Woman,” I speak with leaders in the field to help you learn more about women’s health, pregnancy, and wellness.

Welcome to “Mailbag 39, What Does the Fox Say?” Our first question is from Melissa [SP]. “Hello, Dr. Fox. Love your podcast, so informative and really enjoy how concepts are broken down clearly and calmly.” Thanks, Melissa. “I am curious what your take is on nursing while trying to conceive. I had gotten my period back a month after I went off the minipill, and continued to nurse my baby who was 12 months old at the time. I have gotten my period regularly since then, and my doctor suggested I stop nursing completely as this can be affecting my fertility. I was confused as I was under the impression that once you have a regular period, you can get pregnant and have even gotten positive ovulation tests. My doctor says that those tests and my regular period aren’t enough of an indicator of ovulation while nursing. My baby is now 18 months old. This feels long for me as I’ve gotten pregnant more than once before very quickly. Would love your feedback.”

Okay. Melissa, just full caveat. I am not a fertility expert, but just to give you my take on your question, I would say you’re both right. It’s in the middle. So, for background, it is true that when people are nursing exclusively, usually, particularly in the first 6 to 12 months, they are not going to ovulate when that happens. And therefore, if they’re not ovulating, they won’t conceive. That’s not definitively true, meaning people can conceive while they’re nursing exclusively. We see that. It happens. And for that reason, for people who definitely do not want to get pregnant, we recommend some form of contraception on top of nursing.

So, the question is, well, we know you can get pregnant when you’re nursing. At what point or what might be the indicators that you will get pregnant or your fertility is sort of back to normal, so to speak. So, one of them would definitely be when you start getting regular periods again. When you get regular periods, that is a very, very strong indicator that you are ovulating monthly, though not definitively. Number two, you said you’re getting ovulation predictor kits being positive, which is also a very strong indicator that you are ovulating, though not definitively. Technically, the ovulation predictor kit is assessing for one of the hormones in your urine, LH or luteinizing hormone, which is what typically precedes ovulation, but it does not guarantee ovulation.

So, what I would say is, for you specifically, it definitely sounds like you’re ovulating, you’re getting regular periods, and you’re having positive ovulation kits, a positive test for ovulation on the ovulation kits. However, I think your doctor is correct in that it’s not definitive, and it is possible that nursing is diminishing your ability to ovulate despite these things. And there’s really no way to know for certain what is going on without doing additional testing, meaning you could do…there’s certain blood tests you could do, or there’s ultrasounds you could do, which would tell you one way or another definitively if you’re ovulating. Again, I think most likely you are, but it’s not 100%. But without those tests, you can’t really know for certain.

And so, I think it’s sort of, well, what side do you take? Do you say, well, I’m probably ovulating and I’m not getting pregnant, so there’s a concern, or do you take the other side that says, well, we don’t know definitively you’re ovulating, so maybe we shouldn’t be concerned? And I think that it’s probably in the middle. You could either…again, you could stop nursing, obviously, but if you want to continue to nurse, you could do other tests, either with your doctor or with a fertility specialist to determine if you’re actually ovulating or not, which will sort of let you know whether you should or should not have any concern over the fact that it’s taken you longer to conceive than it has in the past.

And again, also, just as a side note, even if it has taken you longer to conceive, even if you are ovulating, it does not mean there’s a problem, like a fertility problem. Sometimes it just takes a little bit longer. All right. Great question.

Our next question is from someone with the initial S. “Hi. Thank you for the show. I love listening in every week.” Thank you. “After my first child was born, I was diagnosed with insufficient glandular tissue, i.e. not enough milk ducts to create an adequate milk supply. I was able to breastfeed for ‘comfort only.’ Now, I’m pregnant with my second and wondering if there’s anything I can or should be doing to increase my chances of breastfeeding with this one. Do I have any chance of breastfeeding with this one? Also, how rare is this really? It seems like every lactation consultant I talked to had a different opinion about this and about breastfeeding, pumping, formula feeding in general. Thank you again for the show. I learn something new every episode.” Thank you very much for the question.

So, again, I’m not a lactation expert, but I do have some knowledge about this. So, I’m happy to give you my opinion as far as I know. So, what you’re describing is a condition or a situation where it’s referred to, as you said, as either insufficient glandular tissue, sometimes abbreviated as IGT. It’s also been called mammary hypoplasia, which means less growth of the breast tissue, or it’s been called primary glandular insufficiency. All of those basically mean the same thing. Conceptually, think of it as, for whatever reason, some women have less of the milk-producing breast tissue, and because of that, they consequently, after the baby’s born, produce less milk.

So, it is true. It does exist. There is obviously a wide range of how much milk each woman is going to produce compared to another woman, and from pregnancy to pregnancy. And there’s a lot of factors that go into it. And one of it could be sort of the relative volume, so to speak, of breast tissue or the makeup of the breast tissue, how much of it would be milk-producing versus not milk-producing. So, it does exist conceptually.

You are correct that you will get a lot of different opinions on it. And the reason is it’s not entirely clear how common it is. There’s not a ton of really quality, high-level research on it. It’s not entirely predictable who will and who will not produce enough breast milk. You can’t just take the size of someone’s breast and determine, oh, she will or she won’t make enough breast milk. And so, also, as far as we know, there’s nothing that’s been identified that you can do proactively to improve upon breast milk after delivery, at least from an evidence base.

And so, yes, there are probably a lot of opinions you’re going to get where someone might say, oh, I think this might work, or this might work, or this is what I think. But whether there’s research behind it, whether it’s actually going to work in any given individual is very unclear, aside from maybe just getting really good lactation support in general.

So, going back to your question, will you be able to produce enough milk? I would say the answer is maybe. If you didn’t have enough milk in the last pregnancy, it’s entirely possible that you have this…let’s call it a condition, and that it’s going to happen again. But it’s also possible that that’s not the case and you will produce enough milk. And so, if you’re motivated, which I think is terrific, then you should try. You can meet with one of the lactation consultants, see whatever you can do, try to nurse early, all of the things that you try to do. And if it works, great. And then you’ll know that, okay, it was one pregnancy, but not another. And if it doesn’t work out, obviously, I would not feel guilty. This is not something that’s your fault. And of course, if for whatever reason you’re not able to produce enough milk for your baby, your baby can be formula-fed, and everything’s going to be okay. And so, really, at the end of the day, I would say, if you’re motivated, you should try. But if it doesn’t work out, I wouldn’t feel guilty about it, and your baby should be okay either way.

Okay. Next question is from Yiti [SP]. “Hi, Dr. Fox. First, thank you for such an interesting and informative podcast.” Thank you, Yiti. “I’m wondering what your opinion is regarding an IUD placement in a septate or bicornuate uterus. The reason I ask is that a previous doctor might express hesitation in placing one in a misshaped uterus. Is it possible it will be less effective?”

All right. So, this is a really interesting question. This definitely comes up, and it spans gynecology, obviously. So, I don’t really place IUDs anymore in my practice. I don’t do general gynecology. But I do a lot of gynecologic imaging. And we do a lot of 2D and 3D imaging, A, of the uterus in general to see if there is what you refer to as a misshaped uterus. And also, for people who are either considering an IUD or who have an IUD, to see if the IUD is in the right place.

So, to answer your question, a little bit of background. First, the uterus. So, the cavity of a uterus, typically, in two dimensions, is shaped like a inverted triangle. And if you think of it in three dimensions, it’s sort of like a diamond or like a point at the bottom. And it’s wide at the top, or maybe an upside down…or actually right side up ice cream cone, something like that. So, that’s sort of what the shape of the uterus is like.

And an IUD is a form of contraception where you put in a device where basically it’s shaped like a T. The part that goes up vertically goes up the uterus. And then the arms, what we call the T, sort of reach out to each side of the uterus. And it sits typically, if you look on a two-dimensional or a three-dimensional picture with the T is at the top of the uterus, the arms are at the top, one sort of in each corner, and then the vertical part goes down.

And the way the IUD works, there’s sort of two ways based on whether it’s hormones or not hormones, but one of them is it fills the cavity. And it’s sort of…and a typical copper IUD will act as a spermicide. It sort of does not allow the sperm to live. And so, they won’t essentially be able to…you won’t be able to conceive or the sperm won’t reach the egg. And there’s also the ones that release hormones, which can prevent people from ovulating and also make the lining not hospitable for an incoming embryo.

And so, if someone has a uterus that’s shaped differently, if you put an IUD in the uterus, it may not sort of fill the cavity. So, if you have a type of uterus where the cavity is sort of divided into two sections, either what you call the bicornuate or if there’s a large septum, it’s possible that you will place an IUD and it’ll go sort of into one side of the uterus, and the other side will be IUD-free.

And your question is very, very good. Well, if I do that, am I going to get pregnant or not get pregnant? The short answer is we don’t know definitively, and we don’t know if it does increase your chance of getting pregnant, to what degree. Meaning, if let’s say I put an IUD in someone with a “normal shape” uterus and it’s sitting in the right place, the chance someone is going to get pregnant is very, very, very, very low, well less than 1%. It’s not impossible, but it’s very, very, very effective as a birth control.

But let’s say you have a septate uterus. There’s a septum sort of dividing the cavity partially into two sections, and the IUD goes into one section and it’s not in the other section. How effective is that IUD? And it’s probably effective to some degree, but it may be diminished, but we don’t know to what amount. And it might differ whether that IUD is a copper IUD or whether the IUD secretes hormones or not. And we don’t really have great data on this. And since we don’t have great data on this, there’s a lot of different opinions about what to do in the setting of an abnormally shaped uterus, what we call sometimes uterine anomaly or a Mullerian anomalies. And you’re going to get a lot of different opinions.

I think that if the cavity is truly divided into two and there’s two separate cavities or almost two separate cavities, I would personally be concerned that the IUD would not be effective enough for someone. I know people sometimes consider putting in two IUDs, one in each side. Again, I don’t know if that’s better or not, or how many people ever tried that before versus someone who has a cavity that’s just slightly misshapen. Maybe it’s a little bit indented at the top. And when you put the IUD in, it’s basically in the right place.

And I think that you’re going to get a lot of different opinions, and it has to be very, very individualized based on, number one, exactly what is the shape or misshape of your uterus. That’s number one. Number two, if you have an IUD placed, exactly how does it lie? How does it sort of fall into place, which you can only determine with a really good ultrasound using 3D imaging? Number three, is it a copper IUD versus a hormonal IUD? And number four, how critical is it for you to not get pregnant? If someone’s like, well, I’d rather not get pregnant, but if I did, okay, then that changes it.

Now, it is a little bit complicated to get pregnant with an IUD because there’s an increased chance of an ectopic pregnancy. And also, if you get pregnant, there’s a little bit more complications and whether you pull the IUD, whatever. But all those factors have to be put together in order to determine whether it’s worth even trying an IUD as contraception versus trying something else. So, I can’t answer your question precisely without knowing all those details, but that’s sort of what goes into that type of decision when someone is thinking of an IUD and their uterus has any form of abnormality, let’s call it, or misshaped, as you said.

Okay. Next question is from Meg. “Hi, Dr. Fox. I had a C-section at 40 weeks because my baby was OP and failure to descend. My operative report stated, ‘Primary, low, transverse, U-shaped uterine incision, multiple layered uterine closure.’ Then later the report goes on to say, ‘The uterus was then scored and a U-shaped uterine incision was made with the scalpel. This incision was extended superiorly and inferiorly, and the amniotic sac was entered.’ I asked the doctor and she said this doesn’t increase my risk of uterine rupture, and that she just makes a slight curve to avoid the large uterine vessels. My questions are, is this a common incision as I haven’t seen this terminology often and can’t find much online about it? And do you agree it’s safe for a TOLAC? I’d be interested to learn more about the types of uterine incisions and when/why they’re used and how they affect VBACs. Thank you very much.”

All right, really interesting question. So, as background, when we do a C-section, the most common type of incision we make on the uterus is what we call a low transverse incision. And so, what does low and transverse mean? Low means low down on the uterus or the bottom portion of the uterus, and transverse means the incision or the cut on the uterus is side to side, like from your left to your right or from your right to your left. That’s the most common type of incision, which is what they describe primary, which means it’s your first C-section, low transverse.

Now, when they wrote U-shaped incision, I agree that just reading that makes it slightly uncertain what they meant by that. So, when we typically do a transverse incision, it does not mean that the line is a perfectly straight line left to right. There can be a little bit of a curve to it. So, it’s a little bit more like a smile, so to speak, than a straight flat line. And I think most people who make an incision like that would just call it a low transverse incision, knowing that many, if not most, people who make transverse incisions will frequently make it a little bit U-shaped.

Why do we do that? Like your doctor said, if you go straight side to side, you worry that sometimes if you keep extending that line out to the left or out to the right, that’s where the blood vessels are. So, sometimes you put a little bit of a curvature to it, so it looks a little bit like a smiley face. And so, I wouldn’t typically call that a U-shaped incision. I would just call that a low transverse incision, versus a U, which is really like the letter U, which is the ends of it start pointing straight up towards your head. If it were truly that type of incision, which is not what your doctor said she did, that would be different. Because when we make an incision that goes truly up and down on the uterus, we call that a vertical incision or sometimes a classical incision.

And the reason it’s important is because a low transverse incision is the kind of incision where if you are trying to VBAC in a future pregnancy, the risk of uterine rupture of that incision reopening is typically 1% or less. Versus if you did something like a classical C-section, which goes straight up towards the top of the uterus, the risk of uterine rupture is much higher, probably 5% to 10% or higher. And we typically would not have someone attempt a VBAC.

And so, there are situations where you start with a low transverse incision, whether it’s completely straight or whether it’s slightly U-shaped, where you do have to extend the end straight up on one of the sides. And frequently, you’ll hear someone call that a J type incision. So, the bottom portion of it is sort of like a smiley face, and then on one side, it extends straight up. And a J type of incision, we usually will treat like a classical incision because it goes straight up.

So, to get back to your question, I think, for you, since…not a pun there, for you, Y-O-U. Since your doctor clarified that, no, that’s really just a low transverse incision with a little bit of curvature to it like a lot of us do it, that’s what we typically would call low transverse. Your risk of a uterine rupture, if you were to VBAC, should be approximately 1% or so. And it’s no different from what anyone else does. However, if your doctor had meant like a J type of incision where they had to then go straight up towards the top of the uterus, that would be much different.

Okay. Our last question today is from Tina. It’s a cousin of the last question related to delivery after a myomectomy. “Hi. I am 16 weeks pregnant with my first. I had a myomectomy for an over 10 centimeter fibroid and endometriosis excision in February of this year. My OB has recommended a C-section due to the chance of uterine rupture, her point being my uterus hasn’t had enough time to recover between the surgery and getting pregnant. However, the MFM I met with did not, and thinks I should have no problem delivering vaginally. For context, I’m 31 years old, in good health, and I’ve never been pregnant before. I’m curious your recommendation or thoughts. Thanks.”

Okay. So, Tina, I’m not going to give you a recommendation because I don’t know all the details, but I am more than happy to give you my thoughts. So, as background, which is sort of similar to the last question, a myomectomy is a type of surgery where we remove a fibroid from the uterus, and you have to make an incision on the uterus, remove the fibroid, then close it back up.

And so, the question is, okay, if someone had a myomectomy and then they’re pregnant, what is the risk of uterine rupture with that type of incision? And unlike the data related to incisions on the uterus during a C-section, it’s a little bit more complicated with myomectomies because each incision is going to be different. So, when you do a C-section, like I said with the last question, almost always we do the same type of incision, a low transverse incision, which basically all of us who do C-sections, they’re very, very similar to one another. If you go into any operating room around the country, probably around the world, and someone is doing a C-section and they’re doing a low transverse incision, they’re all going to look pretty similar to one another.

So, when you look at data on uterine rupture after low transverse C-sections, it’s probably reproducible that if you did a low transverse C-section or had a low transverse C-section, what is your risk of rupture? But the issue with myomectomies is each fibroid is different, and each myomectomy is different in terms of where is the fibroid? How big is the fibroid? How deep is the fibroid? Was the incision made side to side, up and down? And all these things are going to differ from person to person. So, it’s hard to aggregate the data from hundreds or thousands of people and give a risk because it’s possible that for some types of myomectomies, the risk of uterine rupture with a subsequent pregnancy is lower, and with other types of myomectomies, the risk is higher. That’s certainly possible.

But we don’t know, and it’s almost impossible to know and say, with you, your risk is X percent because what would I base that on? You’d have to have a thousand people who had the exact same type of myomectomy and follow all of them and see how many had uterine ruptures, but there is no such thing as the exact same type of myomectomy. So, because of that lack of clarity, different people approach myomectomies and future pregnancies differently. And I can tell you how I do it, but that doesn’t mean it’s the only way and there’s other people do it differently.

And so, the way I look at it is sort of how much of the muscle of the uterus was, for lack of a better term, disturbed during the myomectomy. So, for example, let’s say someone had a tiny 1-centimeter fibroid that was hanging off the top of the uterus by a little tiny stalk like an apple hanging from a tree. And it was noticed during a laparoscopic surgery where someone was having, I don’t know, a cyst removed from their ovary. And they said, oh, let’s take that fibroid off. And they grabbed the fibroid and took a little scissors and just sort of clipped that little strip, that little stalk that was holding the small fibroid to the uterus. But the muscle of the uterus wasn’t disrupted at all, like zero, no stitches, no incisions, nothing like that. That’s technically a myomectomy, but I would say, I don’t think the uterus was disrupted at all. And so, probably your risk of uterine rupture is same as anyone who’s probably never had surgery in their life. Probably very, very, very, very low, close to zero.

Versus let’s say someone said, okay, I had a 7-centimeter fibroid in the middle of my uterus. And in order to take it out, they had to cut the uterus, pull out the fibroid, and then close up the uterus with three layers of sutures. Do I know definitively what the rate of uterine rupture is in the next pregnancy? No, but I would say, that sounds to me a lot like a classical C-section. And so, I would be concerned that in the next pregnancy, if she were to labor, that there would be a potential for a uterine rupture that’s higher than typical. And so, I would say that’s probably not safe.

Now, am I right? I don’t know. It’s hard to know what is that risk of uterine rupture? Is it 2%, is it 5%, is it 10%? And so, it’s hard to know for sure, but I would sort of logically think it’s going to be higher. And so, I would be concerned.

There are some people who use criteria based on the number of fibroids or the size of the fibroid or was it deep enough that you had to, what’s called, enter the cavity of the uterus? Meaning, when you sort of cut open the uterus, take out the fibroid, did you go deep enough to enter the cavity? Which of these criteria is best? I don’t know. It sounds like the two people who are giving you differing opinions are really basing it on how long it’s been since you had the myomectomy. Meaning, has there been enough time to heal? So, I’m thinking that maybe it was not such a major myomectomy, meaning maybe they both think it was kind of a small fibroid, maybe not such a big thing, but one of them is like, I don’t know if it’s been enough time to heal, so I have some concern. I’m just guessing here. I don’t know for sure.

For me, if the fibroid was big enough and deep enough, it would not really impact my opinion how far it’s been since the surgery. Meaning, if we’re talking about what I said before, like someone has a large fibroid, they have to go deep and soak the uterus in three layers. I would tell them personally not to labor, whether it’s been six months or six years since that surgery because I would be concerned. But maybe it’s sort of one of these situations where it’s a very borderline call which way to go and one of them is thinking, well, it hasn’t been long enough. So, that’s going to put me over the edge to recommend not doing. Again, I’m just guessing here because I don’t know for sure the details. And so, that’s really my guess.

So, maybe one of the questions could be to the person who’s saying it is not a good idea to be back. Say, well, if this had been a year from now, would you have a different opinion? And if so, why? And then on the flip side, for the person who’s saying it is okay for you to be back to say, is the reason it’s okay because you think this was a very minor procedure, or what is your reasoning? And maybe you’ll get a little more context there. But the situation you’re in where you’re getting differing opinions about what to do after a myomectomy, I would say, is not particularly uncommon. And that’s just because, as I said earlier, it’s very hard to get excellent precise data to tell an individual that, from your myomectomy, this is your X percent chance risk of rupture, and therefore you should do this. So, a lot of it is just the overall gestalt of the doctor either who did the surgery or the one taking care of you after the surgery. And this does come up a lot.

All right. Thank you all. Thanks for sending in your questions. We’ll see you next week.

Thank you for listening to the “Healthful Woman” podcast. To learn more about our podcast, please visit our website at www.healthfulwoman.com. That’s healthfulwoman.com. If you have any questions about this podcast or any other topic you would like us to address, please feel free to email us at hw@healthfulwoman.com. Have a great day.

The information discussed in “Healthful Woman” is intended for educational uses only. It does not replace medical care from your physician. “Healthful Woman” is meant to expand your knowledge of women’s health and does not replace ongoing care from your regular physician or gynecologist. We encourage you to speak with your doctor about specific diagnoses and treatment options for an effective treatment plan.